Lawry’s The Prime Rib overall score: 92*
I’d never been to a Lawry’s before. I had heard good things, and of course we all know the seasonings from the grocery store.
But I honestly did not expect it to be as awesome as it was. The Chicago location is not only set in the beautiful historic McCormick mansion, but the prime rib is by far one of the best I’ve ever had. I would fly back tomorrow just for a repeat of this meal if I could.
We had the Lawry cut, which is $47 and comes with the famous spinning salad, Yorkshire pudding and mashed potatoes.
We shared this, which is why there’s a vertical emergency C-section scar on the meat in this pic (they plated it separately and I re-joined the meat for the photo).
I was blown away by this. It was so tender and juicy, so much flavor, and an incredible cap. I wish they had a location in NYC. They serve it with two types of horseradish: a cream and raw/grated.
Choice of Cuts & Quality Available: 10
You actually have a pretty great selection of cuts here for a place that mainly focuses on just prime rib. next time I’d like to try the rib eye (roasted prime rib which is then grilled and seared) and maybe the English cut prime rib. They’re missing the strip steak and porterhouse, but who cares. I’m not even going to take points away for that, since you have like 19 sizes of prime rib to choose from.
Portion Size & Plating: 10
Portions here are large and you get a great deal of food for the price. Everything is plated nicely, and the table side service for the spinning salad and prime rib cart is truly awesome.
Despite the silly “share charge” of $15, this place is a friggin steal. For $47 we got the steak, potatoes, Yorkshire pudding and a salad.
Although there is no real street side view or windows to the outside world, the bar and lounge area is breathtaking.
They make a delicious martini with Chopin vodka, where the olives are stuffed with prime rib and horseradish. Awesome.
My wife had one of their signature cocktails with gin and cucumber that was incredibly refreshing on such a hot day.
And they even have a side entrance to the bar room with a speakeasy vibe to it, called Side Door. Their bar menu gives you access to some of the delicious food in Lawry’s, but it is mostly re-thought for snack type dishes and pub food.
Specials and Other Meats: 7
The prime rib is special itself here. No real need for other items to be marketed, and if they were, I didn’t pay attention. They do offer any other entrees aside from beef or fish, and I respect the shit out of that. Take this category’s score with that in mind. In other words, disregard it.
Apps, Sides & Desserts: 8
We only had what came with our prime rib; namely, the spinning salad, the Yorkshire pudding and the mashed potatoes.
The spinning salad is called that because they spin a cold metal bowl which tossing it. Romaine lettuce, sliced beets and a thousand island style dressing. Very classic.
The Yorkshire pudding is essentially a pop-over, and it was delicious.
Dessert selections are nice. At first we didn’t order anything. We were full.
But they brought us out an English trifle on the house for our anniversary, which is what we were leaning towards anyway. It was really nice and light. Great cake and great jam.
Seafood Selection: 7
There’s definitely something here for you fans of the sea. Salmon and lobster tails, to be exact. And some sides or starters like shrimp cocktail, of course.
Nothing like it. When you go here, you’ll feel like you stepped back in time. White glove service, extremely friendly and attentive waitresses, but not overcrowding or annoying. Very knowledgeable too, I might add. Here’s the inside of that prime rib service cart pictured above. Heaven.
The bread was basic, but the butter was soft and spreadable.
They paid attention to what we put on our OpenTable reservation, and we were greeted with a ribbon on our table, and treated to a free dessert.
Our waitress knew the Lawry’s Chicago story in and out. The space used to be a private mansion. It is absolutely stunning inside.
This place is beautiful. I mentioned above that it used to be a private mansion (the McCormick family).
I’ve never seen a more elegant dining room.
Nice details in this joint. Check out this stained glass window in the lounge/bar area:
Bottom line, go here! This was my favorite meal in months.
LAWRY’S THE PRIME RIB
100 E Ontario St
Chicago, IL 60611