Steakhouse Reviews

CHECK OUT: MY BUTCHER SHOP

Below is an alphabetical listing of all the reviews I’ve done so far. For a list presented in ranking order, view the leaderboard. For a breakdown of how points are awarded, view the review criteria. To sort my reviews based on the places that received full points for flavor, CLICK HERE. Also worth noting here: This listing pertains ONLY to steakhouses. There are some excellent steaks served up at non-steakhouses that could easily qualify as favorites. To check out some of those, CLICK HERE.

  1. 21 Main: 85 (CLOSED)
  2. 212 Steakhouse: 87
  3. Abe & Arthur’s: 82 (CLOSED)
  4. AJ Maxwell’s: 76 (CLOSED)
  5. American Cut (Tribeca): 94*
  6. American Cut (midtown): 89
  7. Angus Club: 96*
  8. Arthur’s Tavern: 69
  9. Atlas Steakhouse: 78
  10. Beatrice Inn: 93
  11. Ben & Jack’s: 92 (CLOSED)
  12. Ben & Jack’s (44th Street): 90
  13. Ben Benson’s: 83 (CLOSED)
  14. Benjamin Steakhouse (White Plains): 85**
  15. Benjamin Prime: 88
  16. Bistecca Fiorentina: 80 (CLOSED)
  17. Blackstone: 83
  18. BLT Prime: 90
  19. BLT Steak (White Plains): 71**
  20. Blu on Park: 90* (CLOSED)
  21. Bobby Van’s (Bridgehampton): 84
  22. Bobby Van’s (50th St.): 78
  23. Bobby Van’s (54th St.): 84*
  24. Bob’s Steak & Chop House: 88
  25. Boucherie: 95
  26. Boucherie Park: 95
  27. Bowery Meat Company: 95*
  28. Bull & Bear Prime: 84
  29. Butcher & Banker: 89
  30. Butcher & Singer: 90
  31. BV’s Grill: 84 (CLOSED)
  32. Capital Grille (midtown west): 84
  33. Capital Grille (Wall St.): 84
  34. Carnem: 83 (CLOSED)
  35. Cattlemen’s: 54 (CLOSED)
  36. Charlie Palmer Steak: 89
  37. Chimichurri Grill (east): UNRATED
  38. Christo’s Steak House: 83
  39. Churrascaria Tribeca: UNRATED (CLOSED)
  40. Club A: 86
  41. Costata: 94* (CLOSED)
  42. Cut: 80
  43. Del Frisco’s Double Eagle: 97*
  44. Del Frisco’s Grille: 82
  45. Delmonico’s: 97*
  46. Delmonico’s Kitchen: 91*
  47. Desmond’s Steakhouse: 88 (CLOSED)
  48. DeStefano’s Steakhouse: 80
  49. Dickie Brennan’s: 76
  50. Donohue’s: 66
  51. Dylan Prime: 95* (CLOSED)
  52. E&E Grill House: 89* (CLOSED)
  53. Embers Steakhouse: 81
  54. Empire Steakhouse (52nd): 77 (CLOSED)
  55. Empire Steakhouse (54th): 84
  56. Empire Steakhouse (50th): 85
  57. Fogo de Chao: UNRATED
  58. Four Cuts: 82
  59. Frankie & Johnnie’s (37th St.): 79
  60. Gallaghers: 95
  61. George Martin (Great River): 94*
  62. Greenwich Steakhouse: 93*
  63. Harry’s: 86
  64. Hunt & Fish Club: 91*
  65. Ikinari Steak: UNRATED
  66. Jade Sixty: 84 (CLOSED)
  67. J&R (Islip): 65
  68. J&R (Patchogue): 67 (CLOSED)
  69. K*Rico: 92
  70. Keens: 96*
  71. Landmarc: UNRATED
  72. Le Relais De Venise L’Entrecote: UNRATED
  73. Lincoln Square Steak: 91
  74. M. Wells Steakhouse: 91*
  75. Mac’s: 80
  76. Major’s (Woodbury): 69 (CLOSED)
  77. Maloney & Porcelli: 85*
  78. Mark Joseph: 82
  79. Mastro’s: 89
  80. Maxwell’s Chophouse: 88
  81. Merakia: 86
  82. Michael Jordan’s Steakhouse: 84
  83. Morton’s (NYC): 86
  84. Morton’s (Atlantic City): UNRATED
  85. Murtha’s: 70 (CLOSED)
  86. Nick & Stef’s: 86
  87. Nino’s Tuscany: 68 (CLOSED)
  88. Nusr-Et: 77
  89. NYY Steak: 85
  90. Ocean Prime: 90
  91. Old Homestead: 81
  92. Pace’s (Hauppauge): 79
  93. Pace’s (Port Jefferson): 82 (CLOSED)
  94. Palm Too: 86
  95. Palm West: 81
  96. Parea Prime: 83 (CLOSED)
  97. Peter Luger (Brooklyn): 79
  98. Porter House: 90
  99. Primal Cut: 81
  100. Prime at The Bentley Hotel: UNRATED
  101. Prime Steakhouse (Key West): 68
  102. Prime & Beyond: 74 (CLOSED)
  103. Primehouse: 91* (CLOSED)
  104. Quality Eats: 85*
  105. Quality Italian: 96*
  106. Quality Meats: 94*
  107. Rocco Steakhouse: 85
  108. Ruth’s Chris (NYC): 93
  109. S Prime: 88
  110. Saint Anselm: 77
  111. Salt + Charcoal: 85*
  112. Seafire Grill (Bahamas): 70
  113. Shula’s (NYC): 67 (CLOSED)
  114. Smith & Wollensky (NYC): 85
  115. Sparks: 70
  116. The Statler Grill: 73
  117. STK (midtown): 87
  118. STK Rooftop: 87*
  119. STK (downtown): 87
  120. Strip House: 96*
  121. Strip House (midtown): 95*
  122. Tad’s Steakhouse: 35
  123. Talia’s Steakhouse & Bar: 58
  124. Ted’s Montana Grill: 73
  125. Tellers: 88
  126. Tender: 77
  127. Tudor City Steakhouse: 86
  128. Tuscany Steakhouse: 91
  129. Uncle Jack’s (midtown): 85
  130. Uncle Jack’s (west side): 83
  131. Vic & Anthony’s (NYC): 84 (CLOSED)
  132. Village Prime: 82 (CLOSED)
  133. Wolfgang’s (Tribeca): 87*
  134. Yachtsman Steakhouse (Disney): 85

* Maximum points awarded for flavor
** Guest Review

carnivore connoisseur