The Rib Eye

Here’s an alphabetical list of all the joints where I took down a rib eye, along with a link to the full review. Scores out of 10 are for the flavor of the rib eye only.

If you’re looking for anatomical information about the rib eye, then you need to go HERE for a general overview, or HERE for more specifics.

  1. 21 Main: 8/10 (CLOSED)
  2. 212 Steakhouse: 7/10
  3. The Ainsworth: 8/10 (Chelsea)
  4. AJ Maxwell’s: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  5. American Cut: 10/10
  6. Angus Club: 10/10
  7. The Anthony: 8/10
  8. Antique Bar & Bakery: 10/10
  9. A.O.C.: 6/10
  10. Arthur’s Tavern: 6/10
  11. Atlas Steakhouse: 7/10
  12. Beatrice Inn: 7/10 (60-day)
  13. Beatrice Inn: 9/10 (30-day)
  14. Bedford 7 Co.: 8/10
  15. Ben & Jack’s: 8/10 (CLOSED)
  16. Ben & Jack’s (44th Street): 9/10
  17. Ben Benson’s: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  18. Benjamin Steakhouse (White Plains): 9/10
  19. Bespoke Kitchen: 8/10 (CLOSED)
  20. Bistecca Fiorentina: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  21. Blackstone: 8/10
  22. BLT Prime: 9/10
  23. Blu on Park: 10/10 (CLOSED)
  24. Bobby Van’s (50th St.): 7/10
  25. Bobby Van’s (54th St.): 10/10
  26. Bob’s Steak & Chop House: 9/10
  27. Boucherie: 7/10
  28. Boucherie Park: 9/10
  29. Bowery Meat Company: 10/10 (cote de boeuf and tomahawk)
  30. Brasserie 8.5: 8/10
  31. Bull & Bear Prime: 9/10
  32. Butcher Bar: 6/10
  33. Butcher & Banker: 9/10 (tomahawk)
  34. Butcher & Singer: 9/10
  35. Butter: 8/10
  36. BV’s Grill: 8/10 (CLOSED)
  37. Cafe Istanbul: 6/10
  38. Capital Grille (Midtown West): 8/10
  39. Carnem: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  40. Cattlemen’s: 5/10 (CLOSED)
  41. Charlie Palmer Steak: 9/10
  42. Chimichurri Grill (East): 8/10
  43. Christos: 7/10
  44. Churrascaria Tribeca: 8/10
  45. The Clocktower: 9/10
  46. Club A: 8/10
  47. Club Car at Gallow Green: 8/10
  48. Cochon Restaurant (New Orleans): 5/10
  49. Corkbuzz Wine Studio: 7/10
  50. Costata: 10/10 (CLOSED)
  51. Cut: 8/10
  52. Decoy: 8/10
  53. Del Frisco’s Double Eagle: 10/10
  54. Del Frisco’s Grille: 8/10
  55. Delmonico’s: 10/10 (Signature Delmonico)
  56. Delmonico’s: 10/10 (45-day Dry-Aged Bone-In)
  57. Delmonico’s: 8/10 (28-Day Dry Aged Tomahawk For Two)
  58. Delmonico’s Kitchen: 10/10
  59. Desmond’s Steakhouse: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  60. DeStefano’s Steakhouse: 8/10
  61. Dickie Brennan’s: 8/10
  62. Dylan Prime: 10/10
  63. E&E Grill House: 10/10 (CLOSED)
  64. El Toro Blanco: 8/10
  65. Embers Steakhouse: 9/10
  66. Empire Steakhouse (52nd): 7/10 (CLOSED)
  67. Empire Steakhouse (54th): 8/10
  68. Empire Steakhouse (50th): 9/10
  69. The Fat Monk: 8/10
  70. Felix: 7/10
  71. Fogo de Chao: 9/10
  72. Frankie & Johnnie’s (37th St.): 9/10 (Rib Eye for Two)
  73. Frankie & Johnnie’s (37th St.): 7/10
  74. Galatoire’s (New Orleans): 9/10
  75. Gallaghers: 9/10
  76. George Martin (Great River): 10/10
  77. Greenwich Steakhouse: 10/10 (Cajun)
  78. Greenwich Steakhouse: 7/10 (48oz Tomahawk)
  79. Harold’s Meat + Three: 7/10
  80. Harry’s: 8/10 (Bone-In)
  81. Harry’s: 8/10 (Boneless Cajun)
  82. Hunt & Fish Club: 10/10
  83. Ikinari Steak: 7/10
  84. J&R (Islip): 5/10
  85. J&R (Patchogue): 6/10 (CLOSED)
  86. Jade Sixty: 8/10
  87. Jubilee: 8/10
  88. K*Rico: 9/10
  89. Keens: 8/10 (limited availability)
  90. L’Express: 6/10
  91. Landmarc: 6/10
  92. Le Turtle: 9/10
  93. Lincoln Square Steak: 9/10
  94. The Lobster Club: 10/10
  95. M. Wells Steakhouse: 10/10
  96. Mac’s: 6/10
  97. Machiavelli: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  98. Madame Vo: 7/10
  99. Major’s (Woodbury): 7/10 (CLOSED)
  100. Maloney & Porcelli: 10/10
  101. Marc Forgione: 10/10
  102. Mark Joseph: 8/10
  103. Mastro’s: 10/10
  104. Minetta Tavern: 9/10
  105. Morton’s (NYC): 9/10
  106. Morton’s (Atlantic City): 9/10
  107. Murtha’s: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  108. Nick & Stef’s: 9/10
  109. Nino’s Tuscany: 5/10 (CLOSED)
  110. Nusr-Et: 9/10 (Tomahawk)
  111. NYY Steak: 8/10
  112. Ocean Prime: 9/10
  113. Old Homestead: 9/10
  114. Oro: 7/10
  115. Osteria Morini: 10/10
  116. Pace’s (Hauppauge): 7/10
  117. Pace’s (Port Jefferson): 9/10 (CLOSED)
  118. Palm Too: 9/10 (28oz bone-in)
  119. Palm Too: 7/10 (12oz Wagyu)
  120. Palm West: 8/10
  121. Parea Prime: 8/10 (CLOSED)
  122. Pasquale Jones: 7/10
  123. Peter Luger (Brooklyn): 7/10
  124. Philip Marie: 6/10
  125. Pig Bleecker: 10/10
  126. The Pines: 10/10 (CLOSED)
  127. Piora: 10/10
  128. Porter House: 7/10
  129. Porter House: 9/10 (Chili Rubbed)
  130. Primal Cut: 8/10
  131. Prime at The Bentley Hotel: 8/10
  132. Prime Steakhouse (Key West): 6/10
  133. Prime & Beyond: 7/10 (CLOSED)
  134. Primehouse: 10/10 (CLOSED)
  135. Quality Italian: 10/10
  136. Quality Meats: 10/10
  137. Rocco Steakhouse: 8/10
  138. Ruth’s Chris (NYC): 10/10
  139. S Prime: 9/10
  140. Saint Anselm: 7/10
  141. Sauvage: 9/10
  142. Scampi: 9/10
  143. Shula’s (NYC): 7/10 (CLOSED)
  144. The Smith: 6/10
  145. Smith & Wollensky: 8/10
  146. Smith & Wollensky: 8/10 (Cajun)
  147. The Statler Grill: 8/10
  148. STK (midtown): 9/10
  149. STK (downtown): 9/10
  150. Strip House: 10/10
  151. Strip House (midtown): 10/10
  152. Tad’s Steakhouse: 5/10
  153. Talia’s Steakhouse & Bar: 6/10
  154. Ted’s Montana Grill: 6/10
  155. Tellers: 8/10
  156. Tender: 9/10
  157. Tessa: 8/10
  158. Tudor City Steakhouse: 9/10
  159. Tuscany Steakhouse: 9/10 (Cajun)
  160. Tuscany Steakhouse: 7/10
  161. Tutti Matti: 6/10
  162. Uncle Jack’s (Midtown): 8/10
  163. Vic & Anthony’s (NYC): 8/10 (CLOSED)
  164. Village Prime: 8/10 (CLOSED)
  165. Wolfgang’s (Tribeca): 10/10
  166. Yachtsman Steakhouse (Disney): 9/10
  167. Zeppelin Hall: 8/10

carnivore connoisseur